THE CRUMB INSTITUTE
HYDRATION 70.0 % DOUGH TEMPERATURE 24.1 °C BENCH REST 41 min
[NOTICE: THE BENCH WAS CHECKED FOR LEVEL AT 08:00 AND WAS LEVEL] — FLOUR STORE HELD AT 14.2 °C AND 51 % RELATIVE HUMIDITY — VESSEL PLACED AND TARED TO ZERO — 350.0 g OF WATER ADMITTED AT 21.4 °C IN A SINGLE CONTINUOUS POUR — SALT WEIGHED SEPARATELY AS SPECIFIED, 9.0 g — THE STIRRING WAS JUDGED TOO FAST AND WAS SLOWED — THE OVEN TIMER IS SET TO 38 MINUTES AND NOT TO 79 MINUTES — [NOTICE: THE BENCH WAS CHECKED FOR LEVEL AT 08:00 AND WAS LEVEL] — FLOUR STORE HELD AT 14.2 °C AND 51 % RELATIVE HUMIDITY — VESSEL PLACED AND TARED TO ZERO — 350.0 g OF WATER ADMITTED AT 21.4 °C IN A SINGLE CONTINUOUS POUR — SALT WEIGHED SEPARATELY AS SPECIFIED, 9.0 g — THE STIRRING WAS JUDGED TOO FAST AND WAS SLOWED — THE OVEN TIMER IS SET TO 38 MINUTES AND NOT TO 79 MINUTES —
Institute working note 4,102

Bread technologyC.R.U.M.B.

[C]rust [R]heology [U]nder [M]oisture [B]oundaries

We weighed 500.0 g of strong white flour on a balance reading to 0.1 g, added 350.0 g of water at 21.4 °C, and left the mixture to stand for 41 minutes. This document describes that procedure in the order in which it was performed. The Institute has repeated it 11,000 times. The mass has not changed.

Section 1 // the balance

The weighing of flour, considered as a measurement problem

Before anything else occurs, the mass of the flour must be established. The Institute uses a flat balance with a resolution of 0.1 g, standing on a bench that is checked for level every Monday morning. The vessel is placed on the pan and tared. Flour is then added from a scoop until the reading reaches 500.0 g, which takes between eleven and forty seconds depending on the flour and on the keeper.

mf = mtotal − mvessel 500.0 g = 812.3 g − 312.3 g tare uncertainty: σ(mf) = √( σ²(mtotal) + σ²(mvessel) ) = 0.14 g

Water is added next. The quantity of water is not selected; it follows from the hydration ratio, which is the only number in this document that anybody has ever asked about. Hydration is expressed in grams of water per hundred grams of flour, and it is not a percentage of the total mass, a distinction we have had to make in writing four times.

mw = ( H / 100 ) · mf 350.0 g = ( 70.0 / 100 ) · 500.0 g dough temperature after mixing: Td = 24.1 °C (target 24.0 °C)

Salt is added at 1.8 % of the flour mass, which is 9.0 g, and it is weighed on the same balance in a separate vessel. Adding the salt to the flour before the water would be a different experiment and is treated as such in the crumb lattice paper.

The procedure continues in the research index and the instrumentation is documented in the instrument API.

Flour mass, mf
500.0 g
Established by tare and re-tare, four times, on a bench verified level on Monday.
Hydration, H
70.0 %
Grams of water per hundred grams of flour. Not a percentage of the total.
Salt fraction, s
1.8 %
9.0 g. Weighed separately, dissolved first, added last.
Bench console [procedure 4,102 / local emulation] Status: bench level, timer idle
[09:14:02] Vessel placed. Tare accepted. Net zero confirmed.
[09:14:38] Flour added incrementally. Reading stable at 500.0 g.
[09:16:10] Water admitted at 21.4 °C in a single continuous pour.
[09:16:44] Stirring commenced. The keeper was asked to stir more slowly.
Section 2 // procedure

Four stages, performed in this order

STAGE 01

Weighing

Flour, water and salt are established as masses on a single balance. Nothing is estimated. A recipe that says "a cup of flour" is not a recipe; it is a rumour.

STAGE 02

Mixing

The water is poured into the flour in one movement and stirred for four minutes, or until no dry flour remains at the bottom of the vessel, whichever is later.

STAGE 03

Resting

The vessel is covered and left undisturbed for 41 minutes. The Institute has measured this interval precisely. Nothing observable happens during it, which is the point.

STAGE 04

Baking

The dough is placed in a preheated oven at 245 °C for 38 minutes. The door is not opened. Opening the door is the single most common cause of a failed result in this laboratory.

Recent output

Selected publications

RefTitleSubjectYear
CBI-2026-041On the arrangement of holes in a slice of breadBread2026
CBI-2026-038On the resting of dough: the forty-one minute intervalBread2026
CBI-2026-012Butter and sugar: the creaming method as an ordering problemCake2026
CBI-2025-119On the pouring of batterBatter2025
CBI-2025-088On the measurement of one teaspoon of vanillaFlavouring2025
CBI-2024-233Sifting considered as a sorting operationFlour2024
entrancecrumb-latticeproofinginternaloven-3apichangelogstatus